Multiphysics versus FEA
David Kan | February 14, 2013
In a popular post from last year, I discussed accessing and manipulating the underlying equations in COMSOL. This blog post instigated reader comments, and most of the respondents appreciated, or even required, the ability to look at the mathematical model (i.e., equations) behind the physics. While considering this, I realized that there is more to the story, and with a little perspective, the community could benefit from further discussion.
An Interest in Equations Not Required
First off, let me be clear about one thing: multiphysics is useful to all engineers regardless of their knowledge of theory. This is a fact demonstrated by the wide user-base of COMSOL Multiphysics. So if you don’t have a taste for equations, no problem. Just use the physics putting the material properties and other governing parameters that you’re used to. The equations will still be there, behind the scenes and doing their work, but you don’t have to worry about them.
I like to use the analogy of a car: most of us just drive it. Still, there is a segment of the population that can open the hood of a car, understand the technology, and achieve optimized performance by making changes.
Now, for those who want to understand, in broad terms, what makes COMSOL Multiphysics special “under the hood”, read on.
The COMSOL Implementation of FEA
COMSOL Multiphysics is often thought of as a finite element method (FEM) code. Indeed it should be, since that is the primary method employed by COMSOL. However, the way COMSOL Multiphysics implements this to perform finite element analysis (FEA) is so clever that we patented it.
Traditional FEA focuses on “elements”. These are fixed discretizations, usually associated with a mesh, that describe certain physics or combinations of physics. If you want to analyze a combination of physics for which no elements have been created (a priori) you either have to couple multiple solvers or you’re out of luck. COMSOL, on the other hand, first allows the user to combine physics in any way. (You can think of writing down any system of equations you want.) Then, just before solving, COMSOL initiates discretization “on-the-fly”. So really, it’s like having an infinite number of “element” types.
|The Coefficient Form Settings Window.||The Coefficient Form is one of the ways in which equations can be freely entered into COMSOL Multiphysics.|
What’s the benefit? Full flexibility in your modeling. That is why, when it comes to pioneering applications in multiphysics, COMSOL Multiphysics users have always come first. Just have a look through the COMSOL Conference papers and presentations, and you’ll see an incredibly broad range of combinations of physics and mathematical models.
When you look at the big picture, there are even more benefits: a uniform workflow and the cross-pollination of innovative ideas, just to mention two. It is the patented multiphysics technology of COMSOL that makes this all possible, and will continue to provide a platform of innovation for computational scientists and engineers everywhere.
On Solvers: The V-Cycle Multigrid
Piezoelectric Simulations Webinar
- Applications 5
- Certified Consultants 30
- Chemical 52
- COMSOL Now 139
- Conference 104
- Core Functionality 70
- Electrical 127
- Fluid 90
- Interfacing 40
- Mechanical 149
- Multipurpose 16
- Tips & Tricks 16
- Trending Topics 47
- User Perspectives 82
- Video 67